Traffic&Transportation Journal
Sign In / Sign Up


Hybrid Decision-making Method for Emergency Response System of Unattended Train Operation Metro
Bobo Zhao, Tao Tang, Bin Ning, Wei Zheng
Keywords:decision making, emergency response system, Unattended Train Operation, metro, Ordered Weighted Averaging,


Suitable selection of the emergency alternatives is a critical issue in emergency response system of Unattended Train Operation (UTO) metro system of China. However, there is no available method for dispatcher group in Operating Control Center (OCC) to evaluate the decision under emergency situation. It was found that the emergency decision making in UTO metro system is relative with the preferences and the importance of multi-dispatcher in emergency. Regarding these factors, this paper presents a hybrid method to determinate the priority weights of emergency alternatives, which aggregates the preference matrix by constructing the emergency response task model based on the Weighted Ordered Weighted Averaging (WOWA) operator. This calculation approach derives the importance weights depending on the dispatcher emergency tasks and integrates it into the Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA) operator weights based on a fuzzy membership relation. A case from train fire is given to demonstrate the feasibility and practicability of the proposed methods for Group Multi-Criteria Decision Making (GMCDM) in emergency management of UTO metro system. The innovation of this research is paving the way for a systematic emergency decision-making solution which connects the automatic metro emergency response system with the GMCDM theory.


UITP, 2011, Press kit Metro automation facts, figures and trends- a global bid for automation: UITP Observatory of Automated Metros confirms sustained growth rates for the coming years, 2011. Available from:


Draft EN 62290-2 Railway applications - Urban guided transport management and command/control systems, Part 2: Functional requirements specification, 2011. Available from:

Fu T. Environmental emergency and typical cases [in Chinese]. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 2006. Available from:

Abrahamsson M, Hassel H, Tehler H. Towards a system-oriented framework for analysing and evaluating emergency response. J. Contingencies Crisis Manage. 2010 April;18 (2):14-25. Available from:

Wang D, Qi C, Wang H. Improving emergency response collaboration and resource allocation by task network mapping and analysis. Safety Science. 2014 Dec;70:9-18. Available from:

Scott Å, Tysklind M, Fängmark I. Selection of a representative set of chemical accidents from a complex data matrix for the development of environment accident index. Journal of hazardous materials. 2002 Feb;91(1):63-80. Available from:


Assaf H, Saadeh M. Assessing water quality management options in the Upper Litani Basin, Lebanon, using an integrated GIS-based decision support system. Environmental Modelling and Software. 2008 Oct-Nov;23(10-11):1327-1337. Available from:


Didan K, Yitayew M. Prototype geographic information system for agricultural water quality management using cropSyst. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering. 2009 Jan;135(1):58-67. Available from:

Bianconi R, Galmarini S, Bellasio R. Web-based system for decision support in case of emergency: ensemble modeling of long-range atmospheric dispersion of radionuclides. Environmental Modelling and Software. 2004 April;19(4):401-411. Available from:


Liao Z, Wang B, Xia X, Hannam PM. Environmental emergency decision support system based on Artificial Neural Network. Safety Science. 2012 Feb;50(1):150-163. Available from:

Mao X. CBR adaptation methodology for environmental emergency response system based on genetic algorithm [Master Thesis, in Chinese]. Shanghai: Tongji University; 2010. Available from:

Wang J, Fang W. A structured method for the traffic dispatcher error behavior analysis in metro accident investigation. Safety Science. 2014 Dec;70:339-347. Available from:




Karvonen H, Aaltonen I, Wahlström M, et al. Hidden roles of the train driver: A challenge for metro automation. Interacting with Computers. 2011 Aug;23(4):289-298. Available from:

Lindell MK, Prater C, Perry RW. Wiley pathways introduction to emergency management. John Wiley & Sons; 2006. Available from:


Ju Y, Wang A. Emergency alternative evaluation under group decision makers: A method of incorporating DS/ AHP with extended TOPSIS. Expert Systems with Applications. 2012 Feb;39(1):1315-1323. Available from:


Meng D, Pei Z. On weighted unbalanced linguistic aggregation operators in group decision making. Information Sciences. 2013 Feb;223:31-41. Available from:

Yager RR. On ordered weighted averaging aggregation operators in multi-criteria decision making. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics. 1988 Jan;18(1):183-190. Available from:

Emrouznejad A. MP-OWA: The most preferred OWA operator. Knowledge-Based Systems. 2008 Dec;21(8):847-851. Available from:

Zhou SM, Chiclana F, John RI, Garibaldi JM. Type-1 OWA operators for aggregating uncertain information with uncertain weights induced by type-2 linguistic quantifiers. Fuzzy Sets and Systems. 2008 July;159(24):3281-3296. Available from:

Liamazares B. Choosing OWA operator weights in the field of Social Choice. Information Sciences. 2007 Nov;177(21):4745-4756. Available from:


Merigó JM, Gil Lafuente AM. The generalized adequacy coefficient and its application in strategic decision making. Fuzzy Economic Review. 2008 April;13(2):17-36. Available from:

Merigó JM, Gil-Lafuente AM. New decision making techniques and their application in the selection of financial products. Information Sciences. 2010 Nov;180(11):2085-2094. Available from:


Chen Y, Li K. An OWA-TOPSIS method for multiple criteria decision analysis. Expert Systems with Applications. 2011 May;38(5):5205-5211. Available from:


Ogryczak W, Śliwiński T. On efficient WOWA optimization for decision support under risk. International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 2009 Jun;50(6):915-928. Available from:

Yager RR. Weighted maximum entropy OWA aggregation with applications to decision making under risk. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics Part A. 2009 May;39(3):555-564. Available from:

Yager RR. Prioritized OWA aggregation. Fuzzy Optimization

and Decision Making. 2009 Aug;8(3):245–262. Available from:

Yager RR. On the cardinality index and attitudinal character of fuzzy measures. International Journal of General Systems. 2002 April;31(3):303-329. Available from:

Wang YM, Luo Y, Liu X. Two new models for determining OWA operator weights. Computers & Industrial Engineering. 2007 March;52(2):203-209. Available from:


Fullér R, Majlender P. An analytic approach for obtaining maximal entropy OWA operator weights. Fuzzy Sets and Systems. 2001 Nov;124(1):53-57. Available from:


Wang YM, Parkan C. A minimax disparity approach for obtaining OWA operator weights. Information Sciences. 2005 Sep;175(1):20-29. Available from:

Amin GR, Notes on properties of the OWA weights determination mode. Computers & Industrial Engineering. 2007 May;52(4):533-538. Available from:


Emrouznejad A, Amin GR. Improving minimax disparity model to determine the OWA operator weights. Information Sciences. 2010 Nov;180(8):1477-1485. Available from:

Amin GR, Emrouznejad A. Parametric aggregation in ordered weighted averaging. International journal of approximate reasoning. 2011 Feb;52(6):819-827. Available from:

Grabisch M, Orlovski SA, Yager RR. Fuzzy aggregation of numerical preferences. Fuzzy sets in decision analysis, operations research and statistics. 1998 Jan;1:31-68. Available from:

Torra V. The weighted OWA operator. International Journal of Intelligent Systems. 1997 Dec;12(2):153-166. Available from:


Valls A, Torra V. Using classification as an aggregation tool in MCDM. Fuzzy Sets and Systems. 2000 Oct;115(1):159-168. Available from:

Nettleton D, Muñiz J. Processing and representation of meta-data for sleep apnea diagnosis with an artificial intelligence approach. International journal of medical informatics. 2001 Feb;63(1):77-89. Available from:

Uhr C, Johansson H, Fredholm L. Analysing emergency response systems. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management. 2008 May;16(2):80-90. Available from:

Uhr C, Johansson H. Mapping an emergency management network. International Journal of Emergency Management. 2007 Feb;4(1):104-118. Available from:

Wang YM, Luo Y, Liu X. Two new models for determining OWA operator weights[J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering. 2007 Jan;52(2):203-209. Available from:


Jiang YP, Fan ZP. Decision theory and method based on judgement matrix. Science press; 2008 Dec. Available from:

Copyright (c) 2023 Bobo Zhao, Tao Tang, Bin Ning, Wei Zheng

Published by
University of Zagreb, Faculty of Transport and Traffic Sciences
Online ISSN
Print ISSN
SCImago Journal & Country Rank
Publons logo
© Traffic&Transportation Journal